How the IRS Prioritizes Boot Tax for 1031 Exchange Properties; Strategies to Manage Boot (Part 3 of 3)

By Tim Vi Tran, | Dec 16, 2025 | tax basis, recognized gain, Fremont CA, property tax, estate tax, tax, boot tax, commercial real estate investment, commercial property 1031 exchange

Tim Vi Tran, SIOR, CCIM, CEO of The Ivy Group, on boot tax, estate tax, inherited commercial real estate,1031 exchange properties in Pt 3, CRE 1031 Strategies.

In Part 1, “1031 Exchange: How Savvy Investors Keep More Capital Working with This Tax Deferral Tool”, one area we discussed, among others, was “Tax Basis Step-up Erases Capital Gains Tax and Depreciation Recapture”. 

In Part. 2, “Boot Tax and Estate Tax for 1031 Exchange Properties”, we zoomed in on boot tax related to 1031 Exchange properties.

Here in Part 3, we will wrap up boot tax issues: (1) How does the IRS prioritize ordinary income tax, capital gain, cash boot, debt boot, and non-like-kind property?  (2) Why is boot not automatically “bad”, and when can it be strategically smart? 

To watch this as a 13-min video

To listen to it as a 13-min podcast

Disclaimer:

All information shared here in this article, and in all blogs, case studies, and courses offered by the Ivy Group are for general education only, not as tax, legal, or investment advice. Please seek professional advice from tax, accounting, legal, and other professionals.

At the end of Part. 2, we mentioned that sometimes the perfect tax deferral is not worth chasing. It comes down to whether you want to maximize deferral or optimize portfolio fit. Sometimes the perfect tax deferral isn’t worth chasing if the asset trade is strategically better with a little boot.

The IRS order of priority for treating boot tax

The IRS has a priority order regarding which portion of boot is taxed first and how:

1. Ordinary income first (recapture)

• If you had depreciation deductions on the relinquished property, any boot you receive can trigger depreciation recapture up to that amount. That portion is taxed at ordinary income rates (highest capital gains rates).

2. Capital gain recognition

• After recapture, the remaining boot is taxed as capital gain.
• It’s limited to the lesser of the actual boot received or the total realized gain on the exchange. You never pay tax on more gain than you actually made.

3. Priority of application

• Cash boot is recognized first.
• Then debt relief boot.
• Non-like-kind property follows after.

Here is an example:

• You sell a property for $1M with $200K of depreciation taken.
• You reinvest $900K and walk away with $100K cash boot.
• That $100K first gets applied to recapture (ordinary income tax on prior depreciation). If recapture was $200K, the whole $100K is taxed at higher rates. If recapture was only $50K, then $50K is ordinary and $50K capital gain.

Where the boot lands tax-wise matters. Here is a tax rate impact estimates (e.g., what $50K of boot looks like under ordinary vs. capital gains treatment):

1031 Exchange Boot Tax Impact (Example: $50K Boot)

The spread between ordinary vs. capital treatment grows fast as boot increases.

Strategies to deliberately manage boot: avoid, take, and soften tax hit 

Now we address when it makes sense to avoid boot entirely, when it’s actually smart to take some boot, and how to soften the tax hit:

When to avoid boot (maximize deferral):

• Match or exceed value: Buy a replacement property equal to or greater than what you sold, including debt.
• Offset debt with cash: If you’re taking on less debt in the new deal, make up the difference by injecting cash at closing.
• Apply proceeds to qualified costs: Use exchange funds for allowable closing costs (broker fees, transfer taxes, title insurance) so they don’t become boot.
• Avoid taking cash out: Even a small “reimbursement” at closing can trigger boot.

When boot can be strategically smart (flexibility or liquidity):

• Better portfolio fit: Forcing yourself into a larger property (just to avoid boot) may not align with your investment thesis. Sometimes a smaller but strategically better property is worth paying partial taxes. The loss of some deferral is offset by flexibility gained.
• Tax timing: If you’re already in a low-income year, or expect to harvest capital losses, taking some boot may have minimal tax bite.
• Step-up planning: If you anticipate holding until death and passing property to heirs, the step-up in basis may wipe out deferred gains anyway—so partial boot now might not derail the bigger plan.
• Liquidity needs: If you want some cash out for other investments, personal expenses, or to diversify, boot is one way to do that—just plan for the tax.

Ways to soften the tax hit:

• If you’re charitably inclined, direct some appreciated proceeds toward a charitable remainder trust or donor-advised fund—boot could fund giving while offsetting tax impact.
• Pair with capital losses from other assets (stocks, other real estate).
• Use boot to cover deductible expenses you’d have anyway (if aligned with IRS rules).

Depending on your unique circumstances, you can either stretch to stay “pure 1031”, or accept a little boot and use it wisely.  

Boot’s net liquidity after tax: The “2/3 Rule of Thumb”

How much cash you actually keep depends on whether the boot is taxed as ordinary income or capital gain, and your bracket.

Here is the “2/3 Rule of Thumb” that helps frame whether the liquidity you gain is worth the deferral you give up: Every $1.00 of boot leaves you with somewhere between $0.63–$0.80 in pocket, depending on how it’s taxed. 

Use this shortcut test when sizing up the boot, and ask yourself:

• Is the liquidity I get worth only ~70 cents on the dollar? In other words: what can I do with the 70 cents I actually get?
• Would those funds earn me more elsewhere than the compounded benefit of deferring tax through a cleaner 1031?

Quick check:

• High-income year → boot is expensive, lean toward avoiding.
• Low-income year or lots of capital losses → boot is less impactful to your tax liability, may be worth it.
• Long term hold until estate transfer →deferral since step-up wipes the gain, up to $13.9M as of this writing

Here is a visual decision tree you can use as a gut-check for handling boot in a 1031 exchange, it helps you quickly see whether to lean toward avoiding or accepting it, based on your priorities and tax situation:

Below is a step-by-step checklist you can run through during a deal so boot doesn’t sneak up on you at closing. Use it before, during, and after a 1031 Exchange:

Pre-Exchange Planning

• Compare relinquished vs. replacement value: replacement must be equal or greater.
• Line up debt match: if the new loan is smaller, commit cash to cover the gap.
  Estimate closing costs: know which can absorb exchange funds (broker fees, title/escrow fees, transfer taxes) and which can’t (loan fees, reserves).
• Decide your stance: full deferral vs. partial liquidity.

During the Exchange

• Verify with your qualified intermediary (QI) that funds flow correctly.
• Double-check no cash back at closing unless you’re consciously taking a boot.
• Confirm all exchange funds are applied to like-kind property or allowable costs.
• Track any non-like-kind property included (fixtures, equipment) that might create boot.

Post-Exchange Wrap-Up

• Review settlement statements with your tax advisor: spot hidden boot (prorated rents, reserves, lender fees).
• Document the basis adjustments and depreciation schedule for the new property.
• Model the tax impact if boot occurred (ordinary vs. capital).
  Revisit whether the boot received aligns with your portfolio and liquidity strategy.

Think of it as a guardrail: if you check every box, you either avoid boot or at least take it with eyes open. Consulting your tax advisor is highly recommended.

Conclusion

The 1031 Exchange remains one of the most powerful tools available to commercial real estate investors, but only when executed with discipline and the guidance of a seasoned commercial real estate advisor. 

Tax deferral improves cash flow that compounds your investment power, but it is rarely  a one-size-fits-all solution. The decision to avoid boot or pay for it in a wise way depends on your own priority and circumstances such as the need for liquidity or flexibility, and your strategies to adapt, diversify, and change portfolios in response to market conditions. 

It is best to navigate the strict IRS rules with experienced advisors’ professional guidance due to the sizable financial stakes. To avoid an expensive misstep, it is important to work with experienced commercial real estate advisors such as the Ivy Group, qualified intermediary, tax advisors, and legal professionals to accomplish a seamless 1031 exchange.

===================================

A commercial real estate transaction is a multi-faceted process that involves factors such as investment insights, financing, alignment of properties with clients’ specific needs, market analysis, savvy negotiation, communication, tax planning, and other related areas such as accounting, law, technology, and engineering.  

Listing the rules is straightforward; applying them to specific cases is more complex.

In Part 2, we analogized it to  playing basketball, learning all the rules of the game won’t get you anywhere, you need to practice over and again on the court. To win a game requires so many factors beyond experience: mental focus, teamwork, strategies, quick reaction, understanding the big picture, flawless execution, planning the details ahead… 

To learn how these 1031 Exchange and related rules are applied in unique situations with moving targets and various puzzle pieces, you can access, for a small fee, case studies:

👉https://theivygroup.com/course-category/deal-structure-1031-exchange/

About the Ivy Group

The Ivy Group specializes in commercial sales, leasing, and investment advisory across Fremont, Silicon Valley, and the Greater Bay Area. With over 100 years of combined experience and designations including SIOR and CCIM, The Ivy Group provides strategic guidance for complex transactions in commercial real estate.

👉 Subscribe to The Ivy Group newsletter: https://theivygroup.substack.com/

When you need to sell, buy, or lease, the Ivy Group is ready to help you reach your goals with more than 100 years of combined experience and expertise. Contact us with your next real estate needs.

Disclaimer:

All information shared here in this article, and in all blogs, case studies, and courses offered by the Ivy Group are for general education only, not as tax, legal, or investment advice. Please seek professional advice from tax, accounting, legal, and other professionals.

Copyright ©️ 2025 by Tim Vi Tran, SIOR, CCIM. All rights reserved.

Previous Next